Bratt bank robber gets eight years

Tuesday December 4, 2012

BRATTLEBORO -- A Massachusetts man will serve up to eight years in prison after admitting to robbing a Brattleboro bank in 2011.

Shayne Fleming-Pancione pleaded guilty Monday to grand larceny for the Aug. 13, 2011 robbery of TD Bank in downtown Brattleboro.

Judge David Suntag accepted the plea and handed Fleming-Pancione a prison sentence of eight years to eight years and one day. Vermont law requires that there be both a minimum and maximum sentence imposed.

David Gartenstein, a deputy Windham County state's attorney, labeled the robbery a "serious crime of violence" and said the prison term was warranted.

"The state's position was that a significant punitive sentence for this crime was required," Gartenstein said. "This sentence serves that objective."

Police said Fleming-Pancione, of Easthampton, Mass., demanded that tellers give him all $50 and $100 bills and threatened violence.

"Do what I say, or I will shoot," a teller recalled the suspect saying, though Fleming-Pancione did not show a weapon.

He escaped the bank with $3,050.

A Massachusetts investigation into counterfeit money led to Fleming-Pancione's arrest in connection with the Vermont robbery.

A confidential informant in the Massachusetts probe noted that Fleming-Pancione, who "typically struggled to accumulate small amounts of cash to buy heroin," suddenly was paying off bills and purchasing clothes and a flat-screen television, police have said.

When Fleming-Pancione was arrested on drug and counterfeiting charges in September 2011, Massachusetts authorities notified Brattleboro police. A sweatshirt matching the bank robber's was found at his apartment, and his laptop computer's browser history included several news articles related to the heist, police have said.

A friend told investigators that Fleming-Pancione had admitted to the robbery and had a drug problem. The friend also noticed that Fleming-Pancione had printed about $200 worth of fake $20 bills after the robbery.

"I told Shayne that he really needed to get into detox because this was ridiculous," the friend reportedly told police. "I know that Shayne is good-intentioned with bad desires."

Fleming-Pancione's criminal history includes prison time for two other armed robberies.

He still has a Massachusetts sentence to serve and also faces federal counterfeiting charges there, Gartenstein said.

Mike Faher can be reached at or 802-254-2311, ext. 275.


If you'd like to leave a comment (or a tip or a question) about this story with the editors, please email us. We also welcome letters to the editor for publication; you can do that by filling out our letters form and submitting it to the newsroom.

Powered by Creative Circle Media Solutions